Colonial Christmas Dinners and Tavern Meals in Williamsburg

Williamsburg runs two different Christmases at once this time of year — one lit by candles and staffed by people in tricorn hats, the other lit by half a million bulbs and staffed by people selling hot chocolate — and the trick is picking which one you’re actually in the mood for before you park the car.

Related reading: The 7 Best Free Library Story Times in Williamsburg.

The Historic District, After Hours

Start at the Courthouse, a genuine 1771 Georgian building where costumed reenactors still run mock trials for visitors. It’s open daily, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., which makes it an easy midday anchor before you wander the rest of the district — you’re not choosing between this and dinner, you’re doing this on the way to dinner. It’s one of the more convincing pieces of the historic area precisely because the building isn’t a reconstruction; the courtroom drama is staged, the walls aren’t.

Christmas Town, If You Want the Other Register Entirely

Busch Gardens’ Christmas Town is the maximalist answer to the same season — a theme park given over entirely to lights and seasonal programming rather than roller coasters. It’s a different kind of evening than the historic district: less about standing in a candlelit room imagining 1771, more about walking through something built to be photographed. Go on a night you’re not also trying to do the Courthouse; the two don’t blend into one outing so much as they’re two separate ones wearing the same month.

Merchants Square, for the Actual Eating and Shopping

This is where dinner and gift-buying happen. Merchants Square is the retail spine of the historic area — more than 40 shops and restaurants laid out to feel like a period streetscape rather than a mall, open daily 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. It’s walkable, it’s where out-of-town family will actually want to browse, and because it sits right at the edge of the historic district, you can do the Courthouse and a Merchants Square dinner as one continuous afternoon-into-evening without moving the car.

Christmas Mouse, for the People Who Take Ornaments Seriously

Tucked in among the seasonal shopping, Christmas Mouse is worth knowing about specifically because it keeps unusually long hours — 9 a.m. to 11 p.m., every day of the week. That’s not a typical retail schedule, and it means it’s the one stop on this list that still works after a late Christmas Town night or a long dinner: you can walk in at 10:30 p.m. looking for an ornament and the doors will be open. It’s a dedicated Christmas store rather than a general gift shop, so it rewards people who actually collect the things — not a five-minute stop, more a browse.

Putting a Day Together

The honest version of a Williamsburg Christmas day: Courthouse in the late morning, lunch and shopping at Merchants Square, a stop at Christmas Mouse if ornaments are on the list, and then a decision — historic district for the evening, or drive out to Christmas Town and let the lights do the work instead. Both are legitimate answers. Trying to cram both into one night is how you end up rushing the part you actually came for.

---

From Newport News This Week.