Ice Cream and Frozen Treats Around Newport News

If you only make one stop, make it Aux Delices Crêperie • Creamery • Patisserie in Port Warwick. It carries the highest rating of any ice cream spot in the city at 4.9, and unlike most of the other high scorers, that number comes from a genuinely large sample — 450 reviews. A crêperie-creamery-patisserie combination also means it’s built for more than a quick scoop: you can turn a visit into an actual dessert course, pairing ice cream with crepes or pastries, which makes it the better pick for a date night or a sit-down treat rather than a walk-up cone.

More in Newport News: Newport News BBQ: Pit Stops, Smokehouses, and Pulled Pork.

The classic neighborhood alternative

For something closer to a traditional scoop shop, The Hilton Creamery at Phoebus is the move. It’s rated 4.7, and while its review count (37) is far smaller than Aux Delices’, that’s consistent with a smaller, more local operation rather than a sign of weaker quality. If what you want is a straightforward, well-loved ice cream counter in a historic part of the city rather than a patisserie experience, this is the one to choose.

Two more small shops worth knowing about

Papi’s Creamery and Delicias Ice Cream Factory both sit in the same strong tier — Papi’s at 4.9 from 63 reviews, Delicias at 4.7 from 80. Neither has built up the review volume of Aux Delices or Rita’s yet, but both are rated as highly or nearly as highly by the people who have gone. These are good picks if you’ve already hit the bigger-name spots and want to try something smaller without any real drop-off in quality.

When you specifically want Italian ice or frozen custard

Most of the names above are general ice cream shops. If the craving is specifically for Italian ice or frozen custard, Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard is the one built around that menu, and it backs it up with both a strong rating (4.7) and the largest review count on this list (522) outside of Cold Stone and Baskin-Robbins. That combination of high rating and high volume makes it a safe, well-vetted choice when you know exactly what style of frozen treat you’re after.

For mix-ins, cupcakes, or build-your-own

City Center Ice Cream is known for a wide range of mix-in ingredients and also sells cupcakes, which makes it a good stop when the group can’t agree on one flavor or when someone wants dessert that isn’t strictly ice cream. Its 4.1 rating is lower than the boutique shops above, which is worth factoring in if quality is your top priority, but the mix-in variety and cupcake option give it a practical edge for picky groups or kids’ outings.

Related reading: Buckroe Beach Summer Eats: Seafood Ice Cream and Grill Stops.

If you’d rather customize frozen yogurt by weight, 16 Handles rates highest among the self-serve-style options at 4.9, though with a more modest 78 reviews. It’s the better fit than City Center if you specifically want yogurt rather than ice cream, or want to control portion size and flavor combinations yourself. sweetFrog Premium Frozen Yogurt covers the same frozen yogurt niche with a 4.6 rating and a much larger review base (519), so between the two, 16 Handles edges it on rating while sweetFrog has the broader track record.

The familiar chains

Cold Stone Creamery and Baskin-Robbins both sit at a 4.1–4.2 rating with high review counts (442 and 355), which puts them below every local shop mentioned above on quality but ahead on sheer name recognition and predictability. They’re worth choosing when you want a known quantity — the hand-mixed granite-slab creations at Cold Stone or Baskin-Robbins’ long-running flavor lineup — rather than when you’re trying to find the best scoop in town.

Bottom line

For the best single stop, go to Aux Delices in Port Warwick — it has the rare combination of a near-perfect rating and a large review base, plus the versatility of a creamery and patisserie in one. Head to The Hilton Creamery at Phoebus instead if you want a smaller, classic neighborhood ice cream counter, to Rita’s if frozen custard or Italian ice is specifically what you’re craving, and to City Center Ice Cream or 16 Handles if the deciding factor is mix-ins, cupcakes, or build-your-own frozen yogurt.

---

From Newport News This Week.